How should the laws of war on Earth apply to wars beyond it?
Kosmos 2542, a Russian satellite that was launched in November, was “like Russian nesting dolls”, said General John Raymond, head of America’s newly formed Space Force, in February. Eleven days after its launch it disgorged another satellite, labelled Kosmos 2543. Then, on July 15th, Kosmos 2543 itself spat out another object, which sped off into the void.
Merely a “small space vehicle” to inspect other satellites, said the Russians. Nonsense, said the Americans; it was a projectile. The intent, said Christoper Ford, the State Department’s top arms-control official, was to signal Russia’s ability to destroy other nations’ satellites. Anti-satellite weapons are not new. During the cold war, America and the Soviet Union developed several ways to blow up, ram, dazzle and even nuke each other’s satellites. The countries conducted twodozen anti-satellite tests between them. Ten were “kinetic”, involving a projectile physically striking a target.
But new competitors, and new technologies, mean anti-satellite warfare is a hot topic once again. China has conducted ten tests over the past 15 years, including a kinetic one in 2007 that created a great deal of space debris. India conducted its first kinetic test in 2019. America, Russia and China have all manoeuvred their satellites close to others, sometimes provocatively so. New methods of attack are being tested, including lasers and cyber-attacks. There is little in the way of law or custom to restrain this new arms race.
Alarmed by the risks, several groups of diplomats and lawyers are trying to change that, and work out how to extend the laws that cover Earth-bound war into orbit. They must grapple with several thorny issues that make space war different from the terrestrial sort. Some satellites, such as America’s gps constellation, blur the distinction between military and civilian assets. Over the past decade, America’s armed forces have put payloads on three commercial satellites, and plan to pay Japan to host others on its own navigation satellites. Then there is the question of what counts as an attack. Michael Schmitt, a law scholar, and Kieran Tinkler, a professor at the us Naval War College, say it is unclear whether jamming a civilian satellite would violate the general prohibition on attacking civilian objects. Blowing up a military one, meanwhile, might or might not constitute an indiscriminate (and hence illegal) attack, depending on whether it could have been disabled by other means and ow much debris was produced.
Perhaps the biggest difference between space war and terrestrial war is how long the consequences can last. Much of the debris from China’s 2007 test, for instance, will still be in space at the turn of the next century. The more debris, the greater the likelihood of accidental collisions with other satellites, which generates more debris in turn. Enough debris could lead to a chain reaction known as Kessler syndrome, which could render entire swathes of near-Earth space unusable for decades. For now, there are no widely accepted answers to any of these questions. The Outer Space Treaty of 1967 requires states to consult each other on actions that “would cause potentially harmful interference”, though the rule has rarely been heeded.
Most countries accept that, in wartime, a body of existing laws known as international humanitarian law would apply, as on Earth—something America confirmed in its “Spacepower” doctrine, published on August 10th. International humanitarian law is based on principles such as distinction (between combatants and civilians) and proportionality (between civilian harm and military advantage). But how to apply such ideas in a place with few humans is not always obvious.
In other domains of war, like naval conflict, legal manuals spell out what is and is not permissible. Legal experts are now attempting to do this for space. The Manual on International Law Applicable to Military Uses of Outer Space (milamos) is being spearheaded by McGill University, in Montreal, and a separate Woomera Manual by the University of Adelaide. Both hope to publish their documents next year.
Hitoshi Nasu, a director of the Woomera project, says that—perhaps surprisingly—big countries are genuinely interested in complying with international law in war, if only to deprive their rivals of an excuse to break the rules. The trickier and more pressing issue, he says, is clarifying the day-to-day rules in peacetime, which might help avert a conflict in the first place. Russia and China would like a formal treaty banning all weapons in space. Both are keen to prevent America from deploying space-based anti-missile systems which might threaten their own nuclear forces. America and its allies resist this. They argue that it is impossible to define a space weapon—anything that manoeuvres in orbit could serve as one—and that it would be easy to cheat.
The European Union has instead proposed a voluntary code of conduct. Many non-Western countries would prefer a binding treaty, says Daniel Porras of swf. Though most are not space powers, many are likely to become so in the future, so their buy-in is important. Later this month Britain will publish a draft un resolution seeking views on behaviour in space, with the results to be submitted to the secretarygeneral next year.
A group of experts has met regularly at the unto try to hash out a solution, without much progress. On July 27th America and Russia held a 13-hour “space security exchange” in Vienna, the first such talks in seven years. It produced warm words, but is unlikely to lead to new laws—especially with existing arms-control collapsing. Back in orbit, the problem is pressing. In January America complained that Kosmos 2542 and 2543 had tailed a spy satellite in an “unusual and disturbing” way (American satellites have also sidled up to others in the past). As space gets more “congested and contested”, the diplomats and lawyers have their work cut out.
73287964 Around the World, Top Ten List, Urban Legends, 8277247 Financial and Business, Structured Settlement Annuity, Small Business 27828858
Search This Blog
Popular Posts
-
Best Video Games of All Time This is it, the list you thought we’d never dare to do. Today we’re concluding our series of the best video ga...
-
10 Mysterious Photos Around the World That Cannot Be Explained These are 10 mysterious photos that cannot be explained. 1. The Babushka L...
-
Top 10 Scary Swedish Urban Legends 10. The Silver Train This is a true ghost train story. Locals called it the Silverpilen. In Swedens ...
-
Most Horror Movies Inspired by Real People 15. The Possession (2012) This 2012 horror film is based on the haunted dybbuk box. In rea...
-
Top 10 Scary Japanese Urban Legends 10. Teke-Teke This is the Urban Legend about a girl who fell under a train and was cut in half. Sh...
-
20 Celebs Who Don't Like Taylor Swift Taylor swift started off as a sweet and nice country singer, but she has definitely burned more t...
-
Top 10 Scary Mcdonald's Urban Legends 10. One McDonalds store is entirely run by Robots! Has the AI Takeover begun? The rumour has it...
-
10 Surprising Things You Didn't Know About President Donald Trump He is a real-estate mogul, a reality TV star and currently the most p...
-
10 Video Games of All Time 10 Video Game Easter Eggs 10 Renaissance Characters 19 Renaissance Philosophers 17 Nam...
-
Top 10 Scary Fortnite Creepypastas Creepypastas are typically terrifying legends or images that have circulated their way around the intern...
- The Corona Virus Explained
- My Car Accident Settlement Worth
- Question Ask Mortgage Lenders
- Homeownner Insurance Tip
- Homeowner Need to Know Insurance
- Millennials Choose to Buy Home
- Habits of Wealthy Successful People
- Prepare for Your Property Settlement
- Best Healing Medicinal Herbs Part 1
- Best Healing Medicinal Herbs Part 2
- Strange Fruit Around the World Part 1
- Strange Fruit Around the World Part 2
- Strange Fruit Around the World Part 3
- Strange Fruit Around the World Part 4
- Most Venomous Animals on Earth
- Most Venomous Snakes in the World
- Deadliest Snakes in the World
- Most Venomous Snakes on Earth
- Weird and Gross Candy
- Deadliest Assassins of All Time
- Creepiest Families Scary Secrets
- Most Dangerous Countries
- Most Dangerous Gangs All Time
- Amazing Facts About Slovenia
- Amazing Facts About Australia
- Most Danngerous Weapons
- Countries May Not Survive in 20 Years
- Best Places to Visit in Singapore
- Things You Didn't Know Purpose of
- Best Airports in the World
- Most Visited Cities in the World
- Interesting Facts About Neptune
- Most Beautiful Capitals in the World
- Mysterious Lakes in the World
- Interesting Facts About the Sun
- Amazing Facts About the Sun
- Stars Put Our Sun to Shame
- Events Change the Solar System
- Most Evil People in History
- Most Evil Business Men
- Beautiful Places in the World
- Most Beautiful Cities in Asia
- Donald Trump Appeared on Films
- Equation That Changed the World
- Phenomena Faster Than Light
- Biggest Mysteries of Our Brain
- Incredible Lost Inventions
- Unexplained Phenomena
- Strangest Holidays Around the World
- Most Venomous Snakes on Earth
- Deadliest Female Serial Killers
- Oldest Animal Species on Earth
- Mysteries Science Has Yet Explain
- Most Expensive Foods in the World
- Serial Killers Still at Large
- Craziest Natural Phenomena
- Most Successful Indie Games
- Weird Fruit Never Heard of
- Ridiculous Science Myths
- Interesting Facts About Mars
- Discoveries Change History
- Cheapeast Countries Live in Europe
- Cursed Objects Can't Explain
- Most Bizarre Scientific Theories
- Weird Discoveries Can't Explain
- Science Facts No Taught in Schools
- Recent Science Discoveries
- Bizarre Things Found in Space
- Native American Mythology Demon
- Movie Believed to Be Cursed
- Strange Fruit Around the World
- Best Xbox 360 Action Games
- Unsolved Paranormal Mysteries
- Biggest Hacks on Youtubers
- Most Expensive Video Games
- Experiments Can Do at Home
- Science Fiction Predictions
- Urban Legends Inspired Crimes
- Nintendo Switch Games 2017
- Video Games Caused Real Deaths
- Evil Kids in the History
- Mystery of the Bermuda Triangle
- Best Beaches to Visit
- Video Game Records Never Broken
- Strange Things Inside People
- Pets Ate Their Owners
- People Who Mysteriously Vanished
- Mysteries Strange Written Clues
- Most Bizarre Curses in the World
- Most Breathtaking Natural Pools
- Scariest Real Horror Stories
- Scariest Animated Youtube
- Creepiest Urban Legends
- Crazy Fruits Never Heard of
- Scariest Horror Games of All Time
- Insane True Crime Stories
- Scariest Deaths Remain Unsolved
- Battle Royale Games
- Scariest Gaming Theories
- Junk Food Actually Good
- Science Facts Didn't Learn in School
- Scary Movies Based on Real Life
- Android Phone Can Iphone Can't
- Worst Countries to Get Arrested
- Most Dangerous Jobs in the World
- Amazing Places Around the World
- Nintendo Switch Games 2018
- Free Ios Games of All Time
- Unsolved Video Game Mysteries
- Youngest Moms of All Time
- Kids Born Incredible Features
- Scary Cursed Objects Still Exist
- Video Game Easter Eggs
- Scary Things Caught on Video
- Scary Hidden in Video Games
- Kim Jong Un Secretly Enjoys
- Memorable President Trump
- Scary Mysterious Creatures
- Horrible Serial Killers 20th Century
- Rare Beautiful Natural Phenomena
- Beauty Techniques Change Your Life
- Celebs Don't Like Kardashians
- Video Games of All Time
- Most Zombies Movie
- Powerful North Korea Inventions
- Facts About Trump's Vehicle
- President Trump Secretly Enjoys
- Dangerous Beaches in the World
- Horror Movies by Real People
- Celeb Who Don't Age
- Celebs Don't Like Taylor Swift
- Worst Movie Endings
- Most Expensive Fruits in the World
- Famous People Fake Behinds
- Scary Ghost Sightings on Camera
- Surprising About Donald Trump
- Mysterious Photos Around the World
- Cursed Objects Around the World
- Weird and Wonderful Natural Phenomena
- Ways to Lower Car Insurance
- Roads Never Want to Drive on
- Stories Behind Country Nicknames
- Bone Chilling Urban Legends
Blog Archive
-
►
2024
(14)
- ► 10/20 - 10/27 (8)
- ► 10/13 - 10/20 (6)
-
►
2022
(379)
- ► 09/11 - 09/18 (24)
- ► 08/28 - 09/04 (23)
- ► 08/21 - 08/28 (47)
- ► 08/14 - 08/21 (8)
- ► 08/07 - 08/14 (3)
- ► 07/31 - 08/07 (36)
- ► 07/17 - 07/24 (3)
- ► 07/10 - 07/17 (7)
- ► 06/19 - 06/26 (51)
- ► 06/05 - 06/12 (11)
- ► 05/29 - 06/05 (13)
- ► 05/15 - 05/22 (5)
- ► 05/08 - 05/15 (15)
- ► 05/01 - 05/08 (5)
- ► 04/24 - 05/01 (2)
- ► 04/10 - 04/17 (6)
- ► 04/03 - 04/10 (2)
- ► 03/20 - 03/27 (31)
- ► 03/13 - 03/20 (3)
- ► 03/06 - 03/13 (3)
- ► 02/27 - 03/06 (5)
- ► 02/20 - 02/27 (8)
- ► 02/06 - 02/13 (5)
- ► 01/30 - 02/06 (51)
- ► 01/16 - 01/23 (12)
-
►
2021
(687)
- ► 12/26 - 01/02 (17)
- ► 12/19 - 12/26 (5)
- ► 12/12 - 12/19 (39)
- ► 12/05 - 12/12 (29)
- ► 11/28 - 12/05 (35)
- ► 11/21 - 11/28 (111)
- ► 11/14 - 11/21 (53)
- ► 11/07 - 11/14 (1)
- ► 10/31 - 11/07 (2)
- ► 10/24 - 10/31 (13)
- ► 10/17 - 10/24 (14)
- ► 10/10 - 10/17 (15)
- ► 10/03 - 10/10 (6)
- ► 09/26 - 10/03 (1)
- ► 09/19 - 09/26 (3)
- ► 09/12 - 09/19 (3)
- ► 09/05 - 09/12 (2)
- ► 08/29 - 09/05 (5)
- ► 08/22 - 08/29 (4)
- ► 08/15 - 08/22 (10)
- ► 08/08 - 08/15 (5)
- ► 08/01 - 08/08 (36)
- ► 07/25 - 08/01 (21)
- ► 07/18 - 07/25 (1)
- ► 07/11 - 07/18 (1)
- ► 07/04 - 07/11 (16)
- ► 06/20 - 06/27 (2)
- ► 06/13 - 06/20 (3)
- ► 06/06 - 06/13 (68)
- ► 05/30 - 06/06 (8)
- ► 05/23 - 05/30 (1)
- ► 05/16 - 05/23 (18)
- ► 05/09 - 05/16 (49)
- ► 05/02 - 05/09 (23)
- ► 04/25 - 05/02 (14)
- ► 04/18 - 04/25 (1)
- ► 04/11 - 04/18 (4)
- ► 04/04 - 04/11 (3)
- ► 03/28 - 04/04 (5)
- ► 03/21 - 03/28 (11)
- ► 01/31 - 02/07 (1)
- ► 01/17 - 01/24 (3)
- ► 01/10 - 01/17 (15)
- ► 01/03 - 01/10 (10)
-
▼
2020
(559)
- ► 12/27 - 01/03 (17)
- ► 11/08 - 11/15 (3)
- ► 11/01 - 11/08 (5)
- ► 10/25 - 11/01 (9)
- ► 10/18 - 10/25 (7)
- ► 10/11 - 10/18 (14)
- ► 10/04 - 10/11 (55)
- ► 09/27 - 10/04 (19)
- ► 09/20 - 09/27 (21)
-
▼
09/06 - 09/13
(12)
- 3 Suspected Serial Killers Who Were Taken Down by ...
- A legal void
- Conscious uncoupling
- Seeking scale
- Hands off, Uncle Sam
- Financial alchemy
- Xi’s new economy
- Our growing nostalgia for commuting
- Alphabet soup and economic recovery
- What price loyalty at Vodafone?
- Needs must: it’s time to tax homes
- Saving The US Economy
- ► 08/23 - 08/30 (18)
- ► 08/16 - 08/23 (9)
- ► 07/26 - 08/02 (16)
- ► 07/19 - 07/26 (2)
- ► 07/12 - 07/19 (7)
- ► 07/05 - 07/12 (2)
- ► 06/28 - 07/05 (12)
- ► 06/21 - 06/28 (21)
- ► 06/14 - 06/21 (4)
- ► 06/07 - 06/14 (5)
- ► 05/31 - 06/07 (17)
- ► 05/24 - 05/31 (39)
- ► 05/17 - 05/24 (1)
- ► 05/10 - 05/17 (16)
- ► 05/03 - 05/10 (5)
- ► 04/26 - 05/03 (29)
- ► 04/19 - 04/26 (19)
- ► 04/12 - 04/19 (13)
- ► 04/05 - 04/12 (5)
- ► 03/29 - 04/05 (24)
- ► 03/22 - 03/29 (1)
- ► 03/08 - 03/15 (24)
- ► 03/01 - 03/08 (50)
- ► 02/23 - 03/01 (18)
- ► 02/16 - 02/23 (13)
- ► 02/09 - 02/16 (1)
- ► 02/02 - 02/09 (7)
- ► 01/26 - 02/02 (2)
- ► 01/19 - 01/26 (7)
- ► 01/12 - 01/19 (2)
- ► 01/05 - 01/12 (8)
-
►
2019
(340)
- ► 12/29 - 01/05 (6)
- ► 12/15 - 12/22 (1)
- ► 12/08 - 12/15 (2)
- ► 12/01 - 12/08 (3)
- ► 11/24 - 12/01 (3)
- ► 11/17 - 11/24 (5)
- ► 11/10 - 11/17 (20)
- ► 11/03 - 11/10 (6)
- ► 10/27 - 11/03 (9)
- ► 10/20 - 10/27 (40)
- ► 10/13 - 10/20 (3)
- ► 10/06 - 10/13 (3)
- ► 09/22 - 09/29 (1)
- ► 09/15 - 09/22 (1)
- ► 08/18 - 08/25 (1)
- ► 08/11 - 08/18 (2)
- ► 07/21 - 07/28 (1)
- ► 07/14 - 07/21 (26)
- ► 07/07 - 07/14 (49)
- ► 06/30 - 07/07 (18)
- ► 06/23 - 06/30 (1)
- ► 06/09 - 06/16 (39)
- ► 06/02 - 06/09 (34)
- ► 05/26 - 06/02 (22)
- ► 05/19 - 05/26 (7)
- ► 05/12 - 05/19 (8)
- ► 05/05 - 05/12 (2)
- ► 03/24 - 03/31 (1)
- ► 02/10 - 02/17 (6)
- ► 01/20 - 01/27 (8)
- ► 01/13 - 01/20 (11)
- ► 01/06 - 01/13 (1)
-
►
2018
(26)
- ► 12/23 - 12/30 (1)
- ► 12/02 - 12/09 (3)
- ► 11/25 - 12/02 (2)
- ► 11/18 - 11/25 (1)
- ► 08/05 - 08/12 (4)
- ► 07/15 - 07/22 (1)
- ► 07/08 - 07/15 (2)
- ► 04/22 - 04/29 (3)
- ► 04/01 - 04/08 (2)
- ► 03/25 - 04/01 (7)
-
►
2017
(42)
- ► 09/24 - 10/01 (2)
- ► 09/17 - 09/24 (1)
- ► 09/03 - 09/10 (2)
- ► 08/20 - 08/27 (1)
- ► 06/04 - 06/11 (2)
- ► 05/28 - 06/04 (3)
- ► 05/14 - 05/21 (2)
- ► 04/02 - 04/09 (1)
- ► 03/19 - 03/26 (9)
- ► 03/12 - 03/19 (9)
- ► 03/05 - 03/12 (3)
- ► 02/26 - 03/05 (3)
- ► 02/19 - 02/26 (1)
- ► 01/15 - 01/22 (3)
-
►
2016
(5)
- ► 12/04 - 12/11 (1)
- ► 11/27 - 12/04 (1)
- ► 11/20 - 11/27 (2)
- ► 11/13 - 11/20 (1)