google.com, pub-6663105814926378, DIRECT, f08c47fec0942fa0 Around the World JM: Conscious uncoupling


Conscious uncoupling

Has the European Central Bank quietly found a way around the lower bound on interest rates?

Imagine being locked in a dark room. Fearful of slamming into a wall or tripping, you inch forwards, arms outstretched. That is roughly how the European Central Bank (ecb) has approached interest-rate cuts since it first ventured into sub-zero territory in 2014. It knows there is a limit to how low rates can go, and that the limit is near, but, like the economics profession more broadly, it has no idea when it will hit the wall. With growth and inflation subdued, it cut rates gingerly, by 0.1 percentage points at a time. Even before covid-19 struck, its deposit rate was down to -0.5%. Rather than cut rates further, it has since relied on unconventional measures, such as bond-buying. Much of its stimulus has come from expanding its loans to banks, and decoupling the scheme’s interest rate from the main policy rates. With the introduction of dual interest rates, the ecb could well escape its locked room.

Cuts to interest rates are aimed at encouraging firms and households to spend by making borrowing more attractive, and saving less so. But when rates are negative their transmission to the real economy breaks down. Depositors can always choose to hold their funds in cash, which has an effective interest rate of zero. Banks worry that if they pass on negative rates, customers will yank their money out and stash it under mattresses instead. The result is squeezed net interest incomes for banks, a hit to their profitability, and, potentially, a reduced willingness to lend. Economists reckon that at a certain point—the so-called reversal rate—the stimulative effect of an interest-rate cut will be offset by the strain placed on banks. Fear of reaching this point helps explain why no central bank has gone deep into negative terrain.

In order to get around the problem, the ecb has souped up its long-term repo operations (ltros), which lend to banks. When introduced during the euro area’s sovereign-debt crisis in 2011, they were meant to quell fears about banks’ funding shortfalls. Since then they have come in several flavours, from vltros—“very longterm”— to three rounds of tltros, or “targeted” operations, to peltros, for the “pandemic emergency”, announced in April. And the intention behind them has changed. tltros are a way to encourage banks to lend to the private sector. The more a bank lends to households and businesses, the lower the rate at which it can access tltrofunds, according to a sliding scale set by the ecb. And in the topsy-turvy world of negative rates, the ecb is paying banks to extend credit to the economy.

This sort of scheme is hardly unique. The Bank of England has something similar. But one feature makes the ecb’s set-up novel. Until March the tltro rate was tied to the ecb’s benchmark interest rates. But the link has since been severed, and banks that meet the lending criterion can access funds at a much lower interest rate of -1%. The result is that banks can now get super-cheap funding, making a profitable spread when they use the proceeds to make new loans. Meanwhile deposit rates remain closer to zero, preventing savers from running to the door.

So far it seems that tltros have been popular and effective. Whereas the Fed this year has mostly focused on supporting capital markets, lending to banks has made up the bulk of the ecb’s stimulus—hardly surprising given the much bigger role banks play in intermediating credit in the euro area. By August 7th the ecb had lent €1.6trn ($1.9trn or 13% of euro-area gdp) through its lending schemes. In June alone banks borrowed €1.3trn. Once you add these in, finds Frederik Ducrozet of Pictet Wealth Management, the ecb’s balance-sheet has expanded more quickly this year than the Fed’s (see chart). In a speech in June Philip Lane, the ecb’s chief economist, reckoned that the measures alone, by averting a liquidity crisis, may prevent output in the euro zone from falling by three percentage points over 2020-22.

Proponents say dual rates could be more powerful still. There is no technical floor on the tltro rate: it can fall to -5%, -10%, or further. Lower rates could give inflation, long subdued, the kick it needs. Meanwhile the central bank could start to raise its deposit rate, satisfying critics in Germany and elsewhere, who worry about the impact of negative rates on savers. The sliding scale for assessing who gets access to cheaper ecb funding could be altered to, say, improve the transmission of negative rates. Banks could be asked to reprice their existing loan books, suggests Eric Lonergan of m&g Investments, a fund manager; in its most daring form, perpetual tltros could require banks to lend at negative rates—a way of transferring cash to citizens.

The art of the possible
Could dual rates in some form become an established part of the toolkit, at the ecb and at other central banks? The impediments may well be political not technical. If a central bank lends to banks at a cheaper rate than the rate at which it remunerates reserves, then it makes a loss. (At the ecb, these losses are probably more than offset by profits on asset purchases.) Most economists would point out that losses do not matter; central banks can just print more money to pay their bills. But in practice central bankers have been wary of making losses, fearing that recapitalisation by governments might open them up to political pressure and scrutiny.

They may also not want to be seen to be subsidising greedy bankers with deeply negative loan rates: some commentators in France, says Mr Ducrozet, are already muttering that the ecb is doing so. Perhaps it was for a combination of such reasons that Andrew Bailey, the governor of the Bank of England, told Bloomberg on August 6th that he did not expect to follow the ecb’s lead.

Dual rates may also not seem worth bothering with when fiscal policy is the more potent tonic for an economy in a recession. Even the European Union has managed to loosen the fiscal purse strings this time. But a quick, sufficiently large and well-targeted response from governments in the next downturn is not guaranteed. One lesson from the past decade of attempts to revive growth and inflation is that every stimulus measure has a political downside of one kind or another. If dual interest rates hasten the day that the economy recovers enough for monetary policy to be tightened, then surely they are worth having.


annuities meaning ultimate assurance property settlement
wealthy and successful man rich choose buy home homeowner know insurance
ask mortgage lenders car accident settlement mortgage application
prepare investing stock shopping without debt factors affecting home loan
credit cards with no debt plan for business loans step buying insurance
choosing life insurance cheap car insurance debt with credit card
type of insurance how to request a claim deposit banks or insurance
need life insurance insure assets and liabilities contract buying a home
happy if in debt pay car installments most car insurance terms
urgent money request loan save money in stocks howto have a home
plan before retirement plan repayment carefully plunging to the depths
cut health care costs handling employee departure put on retailer shelves
low cost promotion guide to office colleagues get TQM traning
unconscious credit cards home to pay off debt want money to invest
credit card addiction manage credit card debt insurance agreement
loans for education lead to poverty what is private fund
overlook insurance also saving on debt do before retiring
homeowners insurance home insurance state farm car insurance
comprehensive insurance commercial insurance cheap auto insurance
cheap health insurance indemnity car insurance companies
progressive quote usaa car insurance insurance near me
term life insurance auto insurance near me state farm car insurance
comprehensive insurance progressive home insurance house insurance
progressive renters insurance state farm insurance quote metlife auto insurance
best insurance companies progressive auto insurance quote cheap car insurance quotes
allstate car insurance rental car insurance car insurance online
liberty mutual car insurance cheap car insurance near me best auto insurance
home insurance companies usaa home insurance list of car insurance companies
full coverage insurance allstate insurance near me cheap insurance quotes
national insurance progressive home insurance house insurance
health insurance quotes ameritas dental state farm renters insurance
medicare supplement plans progressive renters insurance aetna providers
title insurance sr22 insurance medicare advantage plans
aetna health insurance ambetter insurance umr insurance
massmutual 401k private health insurance assurant renters insurance
assurant insurance dental insurance plans state farm insurance quote
health insurance plans workers compensation insurance geha dental
metlife auto insurance boat insurance aarp insurance
costco insurance flood insurance best insurance companies
cheap car insurance quotes best travel insurance insurance agents near me
car insurance car insurance quotes auto insurance
auto insurance quotes long term care insurance auto insurance companies
home insurance quotes cheap car insurance quotes affordable car insurance
professional liability cheap car insurance near me small business insurance
vehicle insurance best auto insurance full coverage insurance
motorcycle insurance quote homeowners insurance quote errors and omissions insurance
general liability insurance best renters insurance cheap home insurance
cheap insurance near me cheap full coverage insurance cheap life insurance
fast cash for house maritime lawyer houston personal injury attorney ocala fl
home equity loan reverse mortgage us bank home mortgage
personal loans for bad credit peer to peer lending home equity loan rates
refinance mortgage personal loan rates first time home buyer programs
cash out refinance home mortgage rates mortgage lenders
geico commercial safety insurance affordable health insurance
insurance companies near me aflac insurance guardian dental insurance
workmans comp medicare part c ameriprise insurance
medicare advantage allstate near me auto insurance near me


Beginner's Cryptocurrencies Track Cryptocurrencies Make Money i.e. Get Cryptocurrencies Initial Coin Offering Asset Invest Cryptocurrencies Drawbacks Cryptocurrencies Future Cryptocurrency Cryptocurrency FAQ Ways to Lower Car Insurance 100 Tips to Save Money Every Day 189 Life Hacks to Save Money 25 Tips to Save on Groceries How to Save on Food The 10 Rules and Tips to Save on Shopping Saving on Shopping 2021 35 Ways to Teach You How to Save Money 10 Tips to Save Your First €100,000 7 Handy Saving Tips to Make It Easier to Save How to Save on Shopping 10 Tips not to be missed 8 Easy Ways to Save Money How to Save on Food: 26 Tips to Follow 35 Tips to Save Money and Optimize Your Budget How to Save on Shopping: Tips to Avoid Unnecessary Expenses How to Reach Your Savings Goals 17 Tips to Help You Save Money Fast Best Tips to Save Money 2021 15 Things You Should Never Buy at Gas Stations Annuities Meaning Finding Travel Insurance For Cancer Diagnosis How Does the Stock Market Work Top 10 Ways to Make Money Online 10 Legit Ways to Make Money and Passive Income Online 10 Ways To Cut Your Health Care Costs The Ultimate Assurance of Buy-sell Agreements 5 Tips to Prepare for Your Property Settlement 8 Habits of Wealthy and Successful People Why Millennials Choose to Buy Home 7 Tips Every Homeowner Need to Know About Insurance 8 Tip on Homeownner Insurance 10 Question You Should Ask Mortgage Lenders How Much is My Car Accident Settlement Worth 200 Business Movement News 150 Financial Tip You Should Know Essential List of Mortgage Application Document Prepare Yourself Before Investing in Stock Shopping is the Right Way Without Debt Factors Affecting Home Loan Rates Using Credit Cards With No Debt Plan for Business Loans Step Before Buying Insurance Choosing Life Insurance How to Get Cheap Car Insurance If in Debt With a Credit Card Type of Insurance How to Request a Claim Deposit With Banks or Take Out Insurance Why Do We Need Life Insurance Insure Assets and Liabilities How is It Different Contract for Buying a House Happy if in Debt Can Not Pay the Car Installments 16 Most Important Car Insurance Terms Want to Use Urgent Money Where Should I Request a Loan Save Money in Stocks How to Have a Home Plan Before Retirement Plan for Repayment Carefully 50 Financial Movement You Should Know How You Can Hit the Heights While Plunging to the Depths 10 Ways to Cut Your Health Care Costs Tips for Handling an Employee's Departure How to Get Your Product Onto Retailers' Shelves A List of Pointers for Low-cost Promotion A Field Guide to Office Colleagues How to Get Your Tqm Training on Track 4 Excuses to Use Unconscious Credit Cards Be Careful Terms of Insurance Agreement Changing a Home to Pay Off Debt Want Money to Invest Credit Card Addiction Symptoms How to Manage Credit Card Debt if Lose Job What is Private Fund Loans for Education 10 Things That Lead to Poverty Do Not Overlook Insurance There Are Also Saving on Debt 10 Things You Need to Do Before Retiring Seed Funds for the Smallest Start-ups Health Insurance Managed Care Can Cost More States Go for Bold Changes Outside Directors: How They Help You Helping Your Children Plan for a Distant Future The Tax Advantages of a Home Office Job Skills Have Declined Firms Say American Get More for Their Money Boost Your Problem-solving Power Finding the Essence of Good Sales People Suggestions on Selling Your Service Firm Warming to the Idea of Customer Feedback It's Timely to Consider Still Another Inequality More Tax Cuts Coming Vice Presiddency Becoming More Attractive Goal Turn Anger Into an Asset Making the Most of Trade Shows Ideas for Making the Most of Time on the Road The Benefits of Smart Inventory Management Policies That Protect a Company's Good Name Market-neutral Funds May Offer Solace if Stocks Tank Bargains in Business Insurance Bills Would Affect the Hiring of Skilled Foreign Workers The Ups and Downs of a Postal Rate Proposal Locking on to Teamwork Nurturing Part Timers to Be Entrepreneurs Holding Things Together When Selling A Location Knowing When Cut The Cord A New Selling Approach Makes Fashion Sense Too Much Team Harmony Can Signal Trouble Oiling The Wheels Of Consumer Satisfaction Networking 101: Seeing And Being Seen Nuts About Snack Food A Jet-Powered Takeoff Grooming For Success Switching to Self Insurance Promoting A World Ethical Standard Help Wanted Desperately How to Get a Yes From Your Banker Lawmakers Have Their Work Cut Out For Them Making The Climb Onto Store Shelves Hammering Home Performance Incentives Have You Seen Your Banker For Your Annual Checkup Protect Your Company's Proprietary Information Adding Some Byte To Retirement Plans From The Ground Up Pluses And Pitfalls In Voice Mail Lawmakers Have Their Work Cut Out For Them Making The Climb Onto Store Shelves Market Bulls Battle A Case Of Nerves Check The Fine Print In Picking A 401 (k) Plan 5 Pitfalls Make Your Work Inefficient Wrong Stock Investing What is a non life insurance 5 things to do if you want to succeed 5 steps Emphasize the use of credit cards correctly Unemployment can be saved by doing 5 steps Obstacles that prevent from saving Want to be rich do these 3 things New to the stock market Change the attitude of saving with 3 steps Home loan Not difficult anymore Start investing is not difficult Come check the finance health Live 3 items for solving the poor 5 wrong financial views Risking destruction 4 things that should not be overlooked for Save money Wise financial planning techniques for the family 5 mistakes checklist when buying insurance 5 reduce the risk of doing business 3 risk levels that must be known before investing Advantages and disadvantages of Requesting a loan Saving The US Economy What price loyalty at Vodafone Alphabet soup and economic recovery Our growing nostalgia for commuting Financial alchemy Personal credit 4 principles of financial success Buying housing is not a big deal anymore Essential insurance How to teach your child to be wise With the use of money 6 Collection techniques That a salary man needs to do How to choose a credit card that best suits your needs Beware The Scammers out to empty your bank account Avoid The Traps Set By Estate Agents 10 Ways To Cut Your Health Care Costs What is the stock market Adjust the idea of adding value to your business How ready are you for down 10 techniques to use money 10 Ideas To Conquer Stocks 10 Year Retirement Plan Factors That Make Your Finances Worse Eliminate 5 Weaknesses to Create Success in SME Retirement Investment Plan Longevity Simpler 5 Secrets to Financial Freedom How to Invest Without Losing Do We Need Too Much Money 8 Alarms When Finances Are in Trouble How to Use Money Saving Techniques Credit Card Debts Not Difficult Anymore Long Term Savings Financial Matters Young People Should Know The 5 Phases of Money Flow Youth Fever for Cryptocurrencies Economy Versus Demagoguery Resistance to Organizational Change What is Production budget What are the Goods in Commission What are Returns on Purchases What are Pre Operating Expenses What is a Technical Organization 10 Types of Credit Securities 5 Main Types of Business Organization What Is a Business Advisor What is the Personification of Accounts What Is Expense policy 6 Stages of Administrative Organization Social Responsibility of Institutions What Is Business Environment Forms of Organization of Economic Entities Top 9 Functions of a Salesperson 7 Duties of an Accounting Clerk 7 Most Outstanding Comptroller Functions What Is Bookkeeping What Are Taxes Payable Armand Feigenbaum Biography What Is Zero Base Budgeting What Is Chart of Accounts What Is Sensitivity Analysis What Is Purchasing Department Origin of Business Management What Is Administrative Organization What is Cost Accounting What Is Organizational Structure What Is Nominal Salary What Is Centralization In Administration What Is Payable Documents What Is Indirect Labor What Is Going Business What Is Commercial Paper What Is Delivery In Business What Is Equivalent Units What Is Income Centers What Is Indirect Materials What Is Purchase Requisition What Is Internal Accounting Control What Is Administrative Management What Is Political Environment of a Company What Is Purchasing Budget What Is Consignment Merchandise What Is Organization Expenses What Is Unpaid Balance What Is Logistics Operator What Is Flexible Budgeting What Is Government Accounting What Is Financial Leasing Companies Mergers and Acquisitions of Companies What Is Acquisition Financing What Is Acquisition Accounting What Is Operating Leverage What Is Top management What Is Operational Audit What Is Cost Systems Who is Vittorio Mincato Initial Public Offering Backed by Venture Capital Who is Vittorio Mincato What Does On Account Mean The Cryptocurrency Tether Whether Cryptocurrencies Will Fall to Zero Primitive Time of the Administration 6 Tips for Choosing Health Insurance What Is a Structured Settlement Annuity Benefits Behind an Annuity or Structured Settlement

Search This Blog

Popular Posts

Blog Archive